Stories:
3057
Members:
748
Submitted Reviews:
8736
Reviewers:
353
Reviews By NannaSally
# Reviews:
46
# Ratings:
46
Avg Rating:
9

Latest Community Reviews

From the Reviewer:
User Rating:
9
Plot Rating:
8
Acting Rating:
10
Replay Rating:
9
Effects Rating:
9
Has Prerequisite(s):
No
Reviewed By: NannaSallyReview Date: 1/26/17 12:25 pm
0 out of 0 found this review helpful.

This first episode of volume 12 appears to be set in Season 3, as Cally is part of the narrative, and she refers to both Dayna and Tarrant.

The Liberator left on a planet Avon attempting to find out information from a Federation Archeological team, but he is not where they expect him to be. Instead he is on a different planet where a group of Proto Logicians had set up a colony and then developed a project referred to as the Greatest Treasure in the Galaxy – which the Federation has assumed is some sort of weapon.

Avon has been coerced by the head of the Archeological team to attempt to pass through a maze within a ziggurat to find the centre of the structure and reveal what the Valuable Thing might be. He is accompanied by a small flying drone which has been programmed to explode if he either stands still too long, or fails to complete the maze within 45 minutes. To navigate the maze Avon must successfully complete a series of logic puzzles – some of which are more obvious than others. The Liberator crew is able to contribute to this process via communicator. He passes gruesome reminders that others have attempted this maze in the past.

Cally is talking to Avon throughout the maze, and the crew are surprised to find him discussing his past which he has never done before. As he progresses through the puzzles he talks about failures that he has survived in the past.

Once he gets to the centre of the Ziggurat everyone is surprised by what he finds – what the Proto Logicians meant by the Greatest Treasure in the Galaxy, which is not what anyone had been expecting.

Questions: Are memories of past failure positive or negative in our view of our present and future? What might a future be if we were just functioning brains and not dependant on our physical bodies?

This is a clever story and certainly highlights some of Avon’s backstory and why he ended up on the Liberator. Some of the dialogue is funny – Avon poses as a ‘Rogue Logician’ which sounds like it ought to be dangerous somehow.

Jan Chappells performance as Cally is excellent, her asides to the other members of the crew are amusing and well done. Paul Darrow as Avon is concise and…logical! His thinking is clear and precise.

The sound effects especially of the drone is very well done, the music appropriate.

Another different type of story from Big Finish.
From the Reviewer:
User Rating:
10
Plot Rating:
10
Acting Rating:
10
Replay Rating:
10
Effects Rating:
10
Has Prerequisite(s):
No
Reviewed By: NannaSallyReview Date: 1/26/17 12:24 pm
0 out of 0 found this review helpful.

One of my favourite Big Finish B7 Productions. An extra to Volume 11

Avon teleports back to the Liberator where Jenna is waiting – only to tell her he has been hurt and everyone else is dead – now they have to escape a pursuit ship attack.

After their escape, Avon does not want to talk about what happened. Jenna decides to leave rather than travel just the 2 of them together, so they go to a handy space station to seek a new ship for her and a replacement pilot for him – they share a drink and the whole story comes out. A mistake on the mission meant that the others had no opportunity to survive.

Avon tries to persuade a pirate to join him, Jenna overhears a stranger reporting his presence to the Federation, and there is a fire alarm, so they flee. The pirate has a different agenda, Jenna is still on the ship. Now they are trapped by the gravity well of a sun and pursuit ships again are threatening them. There are few options, but Avon is determined not to be captured.

The result is definitely surprising – survival and surprises. And Jenna is again made to be suspicious of Avon’s motives – and perhaps we learn a little of why these two never really seemed to get along all that well.

This is really a pure adventure story – no special issues to discuss or ponder – but a great story to enjoy. Again it is amazing the depth of detail included about how space stations may work and the dangers that are common – and even a little about how families handle bringing up children in space. The sound effects are superb, the music non-intrusive. The writing is excellent and some of the lines are truly amazing. Jenna and Avon get more one on one time than they ever get in the TV series. Look out for Probably Illegal and its effects...

Sally Knyvette is very good – she voices her emotional ups and downs and her concerns brilliantly. And of course, Paul Darrow is superb. Really this is a great production I like to listen to over again and again – it is just all good.
From the Reviewer:
User Rating:
9
Plot Rating:
9
Acting Rating:
10
Replay Rating:
8
Effects Rating:
9
Has Prerequisite(s):
No
Reviewed By: NannaSallyReview Date: 1/26/17 12:23 pm
0 out of 0 found this review helpful.

Vila and Cally are on Watch on the Liberator, and witness a pirate attack on a convoy of spaceships. The victims are from Destiny, a planet the crew had assisted in Season One (Mission to Destiny). They follow the pirates to discover their lair and perhaps stop any further attacks.

BUT they find something quite unexpected and potentially much more dangerous.

The Liberator goes to Destiny to warn the government of an impending invasion. Cally and Villa teleport down to a walled community which is largely deserted, and meet up with Pasco, one of the scientists from the first episode, and his wife Lorana.

They discover that although the Nutritope killed off the fungus, the soil was acidic and taking longer to recover than expected. Now the people are having to ration food, and many are starving.
The Federation are involved…

Pasco and his fellow scientists have been harrassed and robbed and forced to leave the city. His daughter is hiding in a Hunger Refuge. So he goes with Cally to find her and bring her safely out of the city.

Many adventurous things now happen leading up to the Federation arriving bringing.....?

This is a story about betrayal by a politician eager for power, manipulation of a government and population by an avaricious Federation looking to take over another population.

Questions: To rescue a population from starvation, is capitulation to tyrany justified? Will this mean conquest with little violence?

This episode is again a story which will make you think about current issues – refugees in cramped, poorly catered camps.

Good sound effects, but more of that clashy music I dislike and find distracting. The story is quite good and certainly well written.
The acting is very good – the guests are excellent – Louise Jameson is an experienced actor from Dr Who fame and more and is very good and a frightened mother, Anthony Byrne as the scientist Pasco is also excellent. And of course we have Jan Chappell and Michael Keating who are both always very well worthwhile to listen to. They both voice extra characters and cover a very large range of emotions. Vila is shown to be his usual unexpectedly courageous self, even behind his declared cowardice.

All in all a good adventure, but again the Rebellion have lost another planet to the Federation…
From the Reviewer:
User Rating:
9
Plot Rating:
8
Acting Rating:
10
Replay Rating:
7
Effects Rating:
8
Has Prerequisite(s):
No
Reviewed By: NannaSallyReview Date: 1/26/17 12:22 pm
0 out of 0 found this review helpful.

Vila has been sent on a special mission, undercover on the Antares which is a freighter that seems to be taking a surprising amount of goods to an unimportant farming colony. He meets up with another new crew member, Jansc, who appears to be very interested in him.

He gets through a locked door to check out what might be in the hold but the answer is surprising. And his new friend is also interested. They discover something truly horrific in terms of human traficking and genetic engineering.

An accident renders the space ship a seriously dangerous place to be, Vila and his friend need to find a way off and a way to defeat the Federation’s purposes.

Questions: Can a government justify slave labour to fulfill a purpose? And how far is too far with genetic engineering? Is it reasonable to allow some people to die to keep others alive?

Frankly, this story is a bit OTT – I am sure that with time genetic engineering will progress to point where all kinds of wondrous things can be done, so that is not what makes this story difficult, but like many Space Operas not only do they have ’10 minutes’ to find a resolution, but the people who had been sedated til now recover in moments and are able to move and think properly….

So – the plot is a bit hmmm, but it is written very well. The special effects are terrific – the sound of the ship breaking up around Vila and Jansc is truly scary.

Michael Keating remains his competent, professional self and his guest costar Samantha Béart is very good as the concerned daughter looking for her father.

Space Opera has never been known for its realism, but if you can look past this – and I guess all fans do – it is quite an enjoyable adventure, but there is unfortunately a lot of lives lost.

But the Federation is foiled, the stolen people freed to a degree, and Vila and his friend are rescued. And Vila gets kissed…..

Community

?>