A waste of one of Big Finish's rare forays into New Adventures territory with a relentlessly generic and mediocre tale. On the plus side, there are a few bright spots of banter between the regulars and the cover's very nice.

A wonderfully atmospheric ghost story with a lively guest cast and the regulars on good form. Sarah Sutton in particular is hilarious as an uncharacteristically grumpy Nyssa. Alas, the story goes a little off the rails in the final episode with an emphasis on cheesy sci-fi and a frankly bizarre take on the supernatural which seems very un-Who like.

A well-written and well-characterised tale of Doctor Who investigating a faux-Batman on an alien world. Although superficially similar to Justice of Jaxlar, thankfully the story goes in a different direction. Personally I'm not a huge fan of the idea of Who meeting the comic-book super-hero world but I certainly can't fault the execution. Nicholas Briggs in particular gives a fantastic performance and his Ninth Doctor is the next best thing to having Eccleston back.

Although rather uneventful and a little dull to begin with, once this story gets going it turns into a compelling and unexpectedly original tale of immortality at a price. There's a surprising but welcome amount of continuity with other Sapphire and Steel stories (both Big Finish and TV) and ultimately this proves to be a spooky, strange and disturbing winner.