Stories:
2957
Members:
741
Submitted Reviews:
8579
Reviewers:
349
< 8.10 - In the Forest of the Night
8.12 - Death in Heaven >

8.11 - Dark Water

Rating Votes
10
25%
29
9
27%
32
8
32%
37
7
8%
9
6
3%
4
5
2%
2
4
3%
3
3
0%
0
2
0%
0
1
1%
1
Average Rating
8.4
Votes
117
Director:
Writer:

Latest Community Reviews

From the Reviewer:
User Rating:
6
Plot Rating:
3
Acting Rating:
10
Replay Rating:
6
Effects Rating:
10
Has Prerequisite(s):
Unsure
Reviewed By: MercuryReview Date: 3/18/19 7:09 pm
0 out of 3 found this review helpful.

This is not a bad episode but it is yet another missed opportunity for a great story by Steven Moffatt as this first part of a two part finale falls well short of its potential then leads on to an even more disappointing second part.

Spoiler Alert

The episode begins with the death of Danny Pink which should be worth a couple of plus points on its own except we then get two episodes full of the 'undead' Danny in the Nethersphere and returning as a Cyberman. His presence in this first part of the story is not nearly bad as in other episodes though to be fair. In the next episode he goes back to being more annoying but here he is OK. My only question mark here is why would such a strong willed, brave, independent, bright and attractive young woman be so attracted to a dull, self righteous, controlling bore that she is willing to risk everything to be with him?!

Clara's reaction to his death is irrational and she totally betrays the Doctor but that kind of reaction to the death of someone you love is believable (just not when it is such an inexplicable love in the first place but we will have to just accept that) and Jenna Coleman acts her role well. She tries to force the Doctor to travel back in time to save Danny. The Doctor refuses and makes an assertion that he innately knows when he can interfere in history and when he cannot and that this is a case which would cause a damaging paradox. This assertion is helpful in the Moffatt era as if you accept it the many occasions the Doctor chooses to interfere or not are made more explainable. The scenes of Clara trying to force the Doctor to save Danny, the doctor's reactions to her threats and his clever response is powerful. The Doctor ultimately reacts in a beautiful way, forgiving and supporting Clara showing the compassion and decency we would expect from the Doctor. The first negative in this episode comes with the Doctor's offer to find Danny in a possible afterlife which is hard to accept as an action he would suggest.

I can just about accept the Doctor offers to 'find' Danny as a way to make Clara feel he tried to do something I suppose but it is too contrived that Moffatt invents a story where Missy is extracting people's 'souls' as they die and then the Doctor decides to search for someone in the afterlife despite never believing in one. Yes we can accept Missy planned events to some extent knowing Danny was due to die but her banking on the Doctor making such a choice to enable her to get him to the Nethersphere is a huge stretch. In the follow up episode this is worsened when it is shown Missy has made such a huge effort just for her to make a strange gesture to the Doctor but that is a criticism against that episode (Death in Heaven) not this one. The annoying thing is there are a dozen better scenarios they could have used to bring about the same situation. Danny and all the others could just have been getting stolen from mortuaries etc and turned into Cybermen and the Doctor could have discovered bodies were going missing, including Danny's and investigated. Instead the contrivance of using the TARDIS telepathic controls to take them to Danny is weak and unconvincing.

Once they are in the Nethersphere a second, bigger issue arises with the sick idea presented that everyone who dies continues to feel what happens to their body, including cremation! This is unnecessary and horrifyingly insensitive for viewers who have lost loved ones, particularly children who make up a large portion of the audience of this family show. I still cannot believe Moffatt put this dumb and awful idea in. It is not needed anyway! They could just have said Missy travels to the point of people's death, hijacks their conscience before death and steals their body to make into Cybermen. Their conscience being stored in the Nethersphere, feeling the anguish of losing their life, their removal from loved ones and guilt of past mistakes would be perfectly adequate. Why include the feeling of pain to their dead body? It is just a sick idea! Even if we deduce that this is purely a result of Missy's interference and that outside of her temporary period of harvesting souls this phenomenon does not happen it still is inappropriate as an idea.

This weird idea's introduction is such a shame as apart from that glaring error things mostly progress really really well with Capaldi putting in his usual superb performance and Michelle Gomez excellent as the hilarious but dark Missy. There are moments which are uncomfortably over the top but mostly it is funny, strong dialogue with quality acting. The writing and direction builds tension as the story approaches an exciting reveal of the Cybermen which is done really well. The suspense of the Doctor not working out who Missy is or the Cybermen's involvement makes for great enjoyment and brings thrills when those two matters are dramatically revealed. The Cybermen exiting St. Paul's Cathedral is a great moment and a nod to The Invasion with the 2nd Doctor.

The threat posed by Missy and the Cybermen and the enjoyable excitement of all the events as well as the excellent acting, effects, designs and some of the better dialogue and ideas hold this up in quality well but although the episode is not outright illogical it is not as credible as it should have been and the effect on the dead is poorly handled so overall I cannot really rate this higher than 5.5/10.
From the Reviewer:
User Rating:
10
Plot Rating:
NR
Acting Rating:
NR
Replay Rating:
NR
Effects Rating:
NR
Has Prerequisite(s):
Unsure
Reviewed By: Lilwink9632Review Date: 2/26/19 12:26 am
1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

Love Capaldi, love Clara, love Missy. Dark Water is an emotional roller coaster from start to finish. I think this episode is highlighted by the scene in the Tardis right after the lava scene. 12 forgiving her and helping her is everything. It shows that though he can come off as dark and grumpy, he is still kind and sweet inside. Missy is hilarious and tremendous. Love her interactions w/ Dr. Chang and 12. Again it's very emotional w/ Clara and The Doctor, and Clara and Danny. Like I just said when talking about the TPO and TBB, the second part isn't as good, BUT it is still good. I personally, love that Missy was just doing this to show 12 that they're the same and that she wants him back as her best friend. The good man thing is okay. The Danny thing is okay. But the ending between Clara and The Doctor here is heartbreaking and beautiful. It was a perfect end to the series 8 arc. I think a very underrated 12th doctor line is when Clara thanks him for making her feel special and then he says "Thank you for exactly the same". Beautiful. And then of course here comes Santa!
From the Reviewer:
User Rating:
10
Plot Rating:
10
Acting Rating:
10
Replay Rating:
10
Effects Rating:
10
Has Prerequisite(s):
Unsure
Reviewed By: AlfredReview Date: 10/12/15 8:27 am
0 out of 0 found this review helpful.

The 1st part of the season's finale is worthy of any era of Who and blessed by the cinematography available today.

The death of Danny, realised convincingly through the truncated phone call, is a startling development that triggers the drama. The ensuing conflict between the Doctor and Clara over a number of riveting scenes drives the plot forward at a quick pace. The Nethersphere is intriguing. Missy is great as a hologram. But best of all is the Doctor's obtuseness to the presence of the cybermen. Even if one has avoided the pre-publicity and leaks, the reveal is on as soon as the skeleton tanks, so redolent of The Tomb of the Cybermen, make their appearance. The dramatic effect of the Doctor's complete lack of insight builds the tension magnificently up to the truly climactic cliffhanger.
From the Reviewer:
User Rating:
8
Plot Rating:
8
Acting Rating:
9
Replay Rating:
7
Effects Rating:
8
Has Prerequisite(s):
No
Reviewed By: adamelijahReview Date: 6/8/15 1:41 am
0 out of 1 found this review helpful.

The story begins with the death of Danny Pink and takes Clara to a very dark place.

The relationship between Doctor and Clara is superbly played. This is Clara's darkest moment and the plan she hatches is astounding in its desperation and is probably one of the biggest betrayals of the Doctor's trust ever shown. However, the Doctor's reaction is marvelous and the way the relationship between the Doctor and Clara shines through is just superb in this scene in the TARDIS.

The story deals with an afterlife in which we finally learn the tragedy that hung over Danny's life and led him to leaving the military and it's a powerful and emotional scene that leads to him being offered the chance to end the pain forever.

Dark Water is a dark, atmospheric, and very emotionally powerful episode that sets up the final episode of the series. At the same time, it should be acknowledged that certain aspects of the episode can be quite painful for people who've been bereaved particularly if they're loved ones were cremated. This definitely required more sensitivity.

Still despite this issue, this story does a great job of drawing viewers to emotionally engaging mystery full of surprise reveals.

Other Recommendations